ABH 0-2 AL- · 64% ALD 0-1 NEO · 49% KON 1-2 GAL · 54% LEH 0-2 PAR · 64% NIC 1-2 REN · 50% BOD 1-2 VIK · 46% LYN 1-1 RAN · 41% ALS 1-2 AL- · 56% SVE 1-2 FSV · 46% ZUL 0-2 CLU · 62% VIL 2-1 ESP · 56% SHE 2-1 WRE · 48% LIL 2-1 LEN · 50% CAS 0-2 SPO · 66% ABH 0-2 AL- · 64% ALD 0-1 NEO · 49% KON 1-2 GAL · 54% LEH 0-2 PAR · 64% NIC 1-2 REN · 50% BOD 1-2 VIK · 46% LYN 1-1 RAN · 41% ALS 1-2 AL- · 56% SVE 1-2 FSV · 46% ZUL 0-2 CLU · 62% VIL 2-1 ESP · 56% SHE 2-1 WRE · 48% LIL 2-1 LEN · 50% CAS 0-2 SPO · 66%
Premier League · Regular Season - 9 Oct 17, 2026 · 16:30 · UTC St James' Park, Newcastle upon Tyne Match Finished · 90'

Newcastle
vs
Aston Villa.

Quick answer

Who will win Newcastle vs Aston Villa?

Final score: Newcastle 0–1 Aston Villa. Before kickoff, 8 of 12 AI models pick Newcastle to win (67%); the consensus was wrong. The AI predicted score was 2–1.

Consensus of independent AI models on TuringStats, updated before kickoff. Not betting advice.

Head-to-head history → Newcastle form Aston Villa form

12 AI models read this match. The plurality on 1X2 leans toward Newcastle (8 of 12 models). The mean predicted score (rounded from all models) is 2–1 at 45% mean confidence (Low band) — see the strip and table below.

Who do you think will win?

Vote before kick-off and compare with AI

Premier League table Where Newcastle and Aston Villa stand right now
— Consensus

Where the panel lands.

Vote share across models. Read this strip first, then the line-by-line table.

Newcastle win 67%

8 / 12 models

Draw 33%

4 / 12 models

Aston Villa win 0%

0 / 12 models

— Model breakdown

12 picks. Receipts attached.

Line-by-line comparison of each system’s call.

#
Model
Pick
Score
Conf.
Reasoning
01
GPT-5.6 Luna
Draw
1–1
63%
Both teams have mixed recent results; Newcastle's home advantage balanced by Villa's competitive form.
02
Claude Sonnet 5
Newcastle win
2–1
52%
Newcastle strong at St James' Park and won the last meeting 3-1; Villa capable but recent head-to-head has swung either way.
03
Gemini 3.8 Flash
Draw
1–1
45%
Both teams have shown inconsistencies and recent H2H results are mixed. A tight match at St James' Park is expected, with neither side dominating.
04
Grok 4.6
Draw
1–1
47%
Recent H2H includes 0-0 and narrow results; Newcastle home but thin context and mixed history favor low-scoring draw.
05
DeepSeek V4 Pro
Newcastle win
2–1
60%
Newcastle's home advantage and recent H2H win over Villa suggest a narrow victory.
06
Qwen 3.8 Max
Newcastle win
2–1
60%
Newcastle's home advantage and recent form suggest a narrow win, despite Aston Villa's strong away performances.
07
Mistral Medium 3.5
Newcastle win
2–1
60%
Newcastle’s home form and recent 3-1 H2H win suggest edge; Villa’s away resilience keeps it close but not enough.
08
Kimi K3
Newcastle win
2–1
48%
Newcastle's St James' Park advantage and physical pressing edge Villa's inconsistent away form; both sides score regularly, so a tight 2-1 home win fits best.
09
GLM 5.3
Newcastle win
2–1
50%
St James' Park gives Newcastle a real edge and both sides typically score; no H2H or form data available, so confidence stays modest.
10
MiMo V2.6 Pro
Newcastle win
2–1
60%
Newcastle's home advantage and recent 3-1 away win over Villa, but Villa's 0-2 victory at Newcastle in January indicates tight matchup; expect a narrow home win with moderate goals.
— Scoreline frequency

How often each scoreline showed up.

7 of 12 models settled on 2–1. That convergence is a strong scoreline signal—many fixtures fan out wider across the panel.

  • 2–1
    7 models
  • 1–1
    4 models
  • 1–0
    1 model
Team news

Confirmed lineups: Newcastle vs Aston Villa

Newcastle

4-2-3-1
M. Jaissle
9 Y. Wissa
9 Wissa
11 H. Barnes
11 Barnes
28 J. Willock
28 Willock
20 M. Fernandez-Pardo
20 Fernandez-Pardo
7 Joelinton
7 Joelinton
6 Nico González
6 González
3 L. Hall
3 Hall
4 S. Botman
4 Botman
12 M. Thiaw
12 Thiaw
67 L. Miley
67 Miley
21 L. Horníček
21 Horníček

Bench: Sean Steur, B. Touré, W. Osula, J. Murphy, N. Pope, F. Schär, D. Burn, A. Dedić, A. Bamba

Aston Villa

4-2-3-1
Unai Emery
11 N. Jackson
11 Jackson
10 E. Buendía
10 Buendía
44 J. Manzambi
44 Manzambi
47 Alysson Edward
47 Edward
35 João Gomes
35 Gomes
8 B. Kamara
8 Kamara
29 A. Wan-Bissaka
29 Wan-Bissaka
5 T. Mings
5 Mings
3 V. Lindelöf
3 Lindelöf
2 M. Cash
2 Cash
1 Z. Suzuki
1 Suzuki

Bench: T. Harwood-Bellis, Pau Torres, J. McGinn, R. Barkley, L. Bogarde, L. Goretzka, I. Mbaye, M. Bizot, Brian Madjo

Season data

Premier League numbers for both sides, when they score and the players who carry them.

Newcastle

4-2-3-1
W-D-L
3-2-3
Goals
12-14
Clean sheets
2
Failed to score
1
Best win run
1
Penalties
0/1
When they score
15'30'45'60'75'90'
When they concede
15'30'45'60'75'90'

Aston Villa

4-2-3-1
W-D-L
3-2-3
Goals
9-12
Clean sheets
2
Failed to score
3
Best win run
1
Penalties
0/0
When they score
15'30'45'60'75'90'
When they concede
15'30'45'60'75'90'

Key players · Newcastle

  • H. Barnes 2 G · 2 A · 8 apps

Key players · Aston Villa

  • N. Jackson 4 G · 0 A · 7 apps
  • J. Manzambi 2 G · 2 A · 5 apps
  • J. McGinn 1 G · 3 A · 8 apps

Top scorers · Premier League

  1. 1 E. Haaland Manchester City 9
  2. 2 A. Isak Liverpool 6
  3. 3 João Pedro Chelsea 5
  4. 4 M. Tavernier Bournemouth 5
  5. 5 R. Cherki Manchester City 4
Venue St James' Park, Newcastle upon Tyne
Referee Jarred Gillett
New at Newcastle M. Fernandez-Pardo (Lille), Nico González (Manchester City), A. Dedić (Benfica)
New at Aston Villa I. Mbaye (Paris Saint Germain), T. Harwood-Bellis (Southampton), L. Goretzka (Bayern München)
— Aggregated insights

What’s moving the panel.

01
Consensus favors Newcastle

67% of models lean home — the clearest cluster on this fixture before kickoff.

02
Low confidence

Mean 45% across the panel with real dispersion — compare unanimous calls vs split tickets in the model table.

03
xG tilt 1.70 vs 1.00

Derived from predicted scorelines (model means), not live match data — useful for pace vs vote-share sanity checks.

04
Match context

Expected-goals tilt and home-field rhythm (see xG on this page) usually explain whether the game stays open or compresses late.

Ask the Council about this match

Pro

10 AI models vote yes or no with this match's last-5 form, head-to-head, live status and the model picks above attached — not from memory. Then keep asking the same council follow-ups.

Match stats forecast

Corners, cards and shots from each side's last 10 matches at this venue, blended with the league average. Pure statistics, not an AI vote.

No AI
Metric Newcastle Aston Villa Expected total Lean Actual
Corners 5.9 4.9 10.7 Over 10.5 51% 9 miss Ask AI
Yellow cards 1.8 1.7 3.5 Under 3.5 54% 8 miss Ask AI
Shots 14.1 12.3 26.4 Under 26.5 52% 31 miss Ask AI
Shots on target 5.1 4.3 9.4 Under 9.5 53% 4 hit Ask AI

Sample: 10 matches per side. Over the last 90 days the corners lean hit 55% of 249 graded matches, cards 58% of 250. Probabilities are Poisson estimates for information only.

Result check

Actual Aston Villa win · AI Newcastle win

1X2: Miss Score: Off
— Match context

Form, history, team news.

Newcastle
#8 · 11 PTS · GD -2
Last 5
L W L L W
6 GF · 9 GA
Recent fixtures
  • Everton 3-1 L
  • Crystal Palace 0-2 W
  • Aston Villa 0-1 L
  • Coventry 4-1 L
  • Hull City 2-1 W
Team news

No major injury updates in the current API snapshot.

Aston Villa
#9 · 11 PTS · GD -3
Last 5
L W W W W
12 GF · 5 GA
Recent fixtures
  • Bournemouth 3-0 L
  • Manchester City 2-1 W
  • Viking 3-1 W
  • Newcastle 0-1 W
  • Fenerbahçe 6-0 W
Team news

No major injury updates in the current API snapshot.

— Head to head

Last five meetings.

NEW 1 · D 1 · AST 3

NEW VS AST
0-1
AWAY WIN
Oct 17, 2026
NEW VS AST
0-2
AWAY WIN
Jan 25, 2026
AST VS NEW
0-0
DRAW
Aug 16, 2025
AST VS NEW
4-1
HOME WIN
Apr 19, 2025
NEW VS AST
3-0
HOME WIN
Dec 26, 2024

Confidence trend

Cumulative average confidence in table order.

First model Last model

Betting tips (AI-signal view)

Educational only — not financial advice. We summarize how the AI picks cluster so you can cross-check with your own staking plan.

  • Lean with the plurality: when 67% of models side with Newcastle, treat that as the default script unless late team news breaks the assumptions.
  • Watch the draw lane at 33% — tight Premier League games often compress toward stalemates when both midfields win the second-ball.
  • If you chase “best bets today” narratives, require alignment between the headline pick and the score-frequency table; conflicting signals usually mean thinner edge.

Odds & analysis (implied probabilities)

Implied fair percentages from the model vote share (normalized to 100%) approximate how a balanced market might price the 1X2 if it mirrored this panel — useful for odds analysis homework even though we do not quote sportsbook ticks here.

Newcastle
~67%
implied lean
Draw
~33%
implied lean
Aston Villa
~0%
implied lean

Over / under prediction (totals)

Model-derived xG sums to 2.70 goals in expectation. A notional totals line near 3 is consistent with that pace (rounded for readability). If your sportsbook posts a similar number, compare juice and live team news before deciding either side of the total.

Handicap prediction (spread-style read)

When Newcastle is priced as the stronger side in the model vote, a −1 handicap narrative only clears if the most common scorelines include multi-goal wins. Cross-check the score-frequency list: if tight one-goal wins dominate, Asian handicaps near pick’em or −0.5 / −0.75 splits often fit the story better than a full −1.5 sell.

BTTS prediction (both teams to score)

With combined offensive weight near 2.70 xG, a heuristic “both teams score” prior lands around 55% yes before defensive adjustments. If several top models forecast clean-sheet pathways, downgrade BTTS enthusiasm even when the raw xG sum looks juicy.

Best bet framing (consensus-led)

Our headline best bet label follows the consensus recommendation: Newcastle win. Pair that with the confidence band (Low) — high dispersion across models usually argues for smaller stake or pass, even when the headline pick looks tempting for a today prediction card on social.

Match overview

Looking for a today prediction on Newcastle vs Aston Villa in Premier League? TuringStats aggregates multiple AI scorelines into one readable page so you can see who the models favor, the mean predicted score shown in the hero (2 - 1; the frequency chart below lists the most common exact scorelines), and implied splits before kickoff.

This prediction hub is written for readers comparing betting tips-style language with transparent model votes — not a single black-box call. The headline read is Newcastle win, with vote shares roughly 67% / 33% / 0% home, draw, and away (rounded).

If you are asking who will win Newcastle vs Aston Villa, start with the consensus strip and model table, then cross-check form and injuries in Match context further down — that order keeps the strongest signals first.

Explore more

Keep browsing today prediction coverage and league hubs.

Related matches

— Journal

Articles linked to these clubs or AI forecasting.

Ask multiple AIs about this match.

10 models vote yes or no with this match's last-5 form, head-to-head, live status and our model picks attached — not from memory. Then ask follow-ups to the same council.