ERZ 0-1 GöZ · 50% TWE 3-0 WIL · 68% JUV 2-0 VEN · 62% BUR 1-2 BLA · 47% SKB 0-2 GEN · 65% BAR 3-1 VIL · 64% BKH 1-0 IFE · 48% SIR 1-1 DJU · 46% ACH 1-1 SIL · 45% VIB 2-0 RAN · 60% KAS 1-0 ALA · 57% KON 0-2 BEş · 59% AJA 3-1 ADO · 66% SPA 1-2 AZA · 53% ERZ 0-1 GöZ · 50% TWE 3-0 WIL · 68% JUV 2-0 VEN · 62% BUR 1-2 BLA · 47% SKB 0-2 GEN · 65% BAR 3-1 VIL · 64% BKH 1-0 IFE · 48% SIR 1-1 DJU · 46% ACH 1-1 SIL · 45% VIB 2-0 RAN · 60% KAS 1-0 ALA · 57% KON 0-2 BEş · 59% AJA 3-1 ADO · 66% SPA 1-2 AZA · 53%

— Research · updated every 6 hours

AI vs humans: who predicts sports better?

On 8,661 match predictions made by real sports fans before kickoff, the humans picked the right result 56.5% of the time; a panel of AI models picked right 58.4% on the same matches.

8,661 predictions by 2,619 real sports fans on 1,814 matches, each set against a panel of about 10 AI models on the same match and graded on the final score (4 May – 22 Nov 2026).

Key findings

  1. On 8,661 match predictions made by real sports fans before kickoff, the humans picked the right result 56.5% of the time; a panel of AI models picked right 58.4% on the same matches.
  2. When a fan went against the AI (2,130 predictions), the fan was right 35.8% of the time and the AI 43.3%.
  3. Taking the fans' most popular pick on each match (1,600 matches), the crowd was right 57.9% against 58.2% for the AI. Always picking the home team would have scored 47.9%.
  4. 48 of 142 regular fans (10+ predictions) beat the AI on their own matches.
  5. Best AI model against the fans: Mistral Medium 3.5, right 59.6% of the time where fans were right 57.4% (5,550 predictions). Weakest: Cohere Command R+ (08-2024) at 51.3%.
  6. Against prediction markets, where people bet real money, the AI lost to the market on 167 settled questions (Brier score 0.208 vs 0.147; lower is better).

Fans vs AI, head to head

Share of correct home / draw / away picks on the same matches.

Fans against the AI panel
Comparison Sample Humans AI
Every fan prediction 8,661 predictions 56.5% 58.4%
When the fan went against the AI 2,130 predictions 35.8% 43.3%
Crowd: the fans' most popular pick 1,600 matches 57.9% 58.2%
Crowd, matches with 3+ fan votes 814 matches 61.4% 59.3%
Baseline: always pick the home team 1,600 matches 47.9%

48 of 142 regular fans (10+ graded predictions) beat the AI on their own matches. 75.4% of fan picks matched the AI.

Each AI model against the fans

Every model on the fan predictions where it had already made a pick, against the fans on those same predictions.

Accuracy by AI model against fans
Model Model right Fans right Predictions
Mistral Medium 3.5 59.6% 57.4% 5,550
Claude Opus 5.5 58.9% 56.1% 8,850
Kimi K3 58.8% 56.9% 7,960
Meta Muse Spark 1.3 58.2% 57.1% 6,378
GLM 5.3 58.1% 56.5% 8,208
Grok 4.7 57.4% 56.1% 8,849
Gemini 4 Argon 57.3% 56.1% 8,850
Qwen 3.8 Max 57.3% 56.5% 8,602
DeepSeek V4 Pro 57.2% 56.1% 8,850
NVIDIA Nemotron 3 Ultra 57% 54.4% 3,179
MiMo V2.6 Pro 56.2% 56.1% 8,850
GPT-6.1 Sol 56% 56.1% 8,850
Tencent Hy4 53.2% 54.4% 3,178
Llama 3.1 70B Instruct 52.6% 50.9% 993
Cohere Command R+ (08-2024) 51.3% 50.9% 993

Humans with money on the line

On 167 settled Polymarket and Kalshi questions, the market price picked the right side 77.2% of the time and the AI panel 66.5%. Brier score: market 0.147, AI 0.208 (lower is better). The sample is still small.

AI vs prediction markets, live record

How it was measured

  • Fans on TuringStats vote home, draw or away on upcoming matches, mostly football, plus baseball, hockey, basketball, NFL, volleyball, AFL, NBA. Only votes cast before kickoff on finished matches count.
  • The AI side is what about 10 models from different labs were picking when the fan voted: each model's latest pick made before the vote, and the panel's most common pick. Ties count as no call.
  • Fans can see the AI picks before they vote, so the two sides are not independent. That makes the "went against the AI" numbers the clearest test.
  • Fans here are TuringStats users who chose to vote, not a random sample of all fans.

Related: AI prediction accuracy report · Do AI models say yes too often?

Data and citation

Download the CSV (one row per fan vote, no user identifiers). Free to use under CC BY 4.0.

TuringStats, "AI vs humans: who predicts sports better?", November 2026, https://turingstats.com/research/ai-vs-human

Questions

Who predicts sports better, AI or humans?
On 8,661 match predictions made by real sports fans before kickoff, the humans picked the right result 56.5% of the time; a panel of AI models picked right 58.4% on the same matches.
What happens when fans go against the AI?
When a fan went against the AI (2,130 predictions), the fan was right 35.8% of the time and the AI 43.3%.
Is the wisdom of the crowd better than AI?
Taking the fans' most popular pick on each match (1,600 matches), the crowd was right 57.9% against 58.2% for the AI. Always picking the home team would have scored 47.9%.
Which AI predicts sports best?
Best AI model against the fans: Mistral Medium 3.5, right 59.6% of the time where fans were right 57.4% (5,550 predictions). Weakest: Cohere Command R+ (08-2024) at 51.3%.
Can AI beat prediction markets?
Against prediction markets, where people bet real money, the AI lost to the market on 167 settled questions (Brier score 0.208 vs 0.147; lower is better).
How was this measured?
Fans on TuringStats vote home, draw or away before kickoff. Each vote is compared with what the AI panel (about 10 models) was picking at that moment: each model's latest pick before the vote, and the panel's most common pick. Both are graded on the final score. Votes after kickoff are left out.
Can I use this data?
Yes, under CC BY 4.0: credit "TuringStats" with a link to this page. The CSV has one row per fan vote and no user identifiers.