ABH 0-2 AL- · 64% ALD 0-1 NEO · 48% KON 1-2 GAL · 53% LEH 0-2 PAR · 63% NIC 1-2 REN · 48% BOD 1-2 VIK · 44% LYN 1-1 RAN · 40% ALS 1-2 AL- · 55% SVE 1-2 FSV · 45% ZUL 0-2 CLU · 61% VIL 2-1 ESP · 55% SHE 2-1 WRE · 47% LIL 2-1 LEN · 49% CAS 0-2 SPO · 66% ABH 0-2 AL- · 64% ALD 0-1 NEO · 48% KON 1-2 GAL · 53% LEH 0-2 PAR · 63% NIC 1-2 REN · 48% BOD 1-2 VIK · 44% LYN 1-1 RAN · 40% ALS 1-2 AL- · 55% SVE 1-2 FSV · 45% ZUL 0-2 CLU · 61% VIL 2-1 ESP · 55% SHE 2-1 WRE · 47% LIL 2-1 LEN · 49% CAS 0-2 SPO · 66%
Premiership · Regular Season - 12 Oct 31, 2026 · 15:00 · UTC The BBSP Stadium Rugby Park, Kilmarnock Not Started

Kilmarnock
vs
ST Johnstone.

Quick answer

Who will win Kilmarnock vs ST Johnstone?

6 of 10 AI models pick ST Johnstone to win (60%). A draw is in play: 4 of 10 models picked it. The mean predicted score is 1–2 at 44% average confidence (low).

Consensus of independent AI models on TuringStats, updated before kickoff. Not betting advice.

Head-to-head history → Kilmarnock form ST Johnstone form

10 AI models read this match. The plurality on 1X2 leans toward ST Johnstone (6 of 10 models). The mean predicted score (rounded from all models) is 1–2 at 44% mean confidence (Low band) — see the strip and table below.

Who do you think will win?

Vote before kick-off and compare with AI

Premiership table Where Kilmarnock and ST Johnstone stand right now
— Consensus

Where the panel lands.

Vote share across models. Read this strip first, then the line-by-line table.

Kilmarnock win 0%

0 / 10 models

Draw 40%

4 / 10 models

ST Johnstone win 60%

6 / 10 models

— Model breakdown

10 picks. Receipts attached.

Line-by-line comparison of each system’s call.

#
Model
Pick
Score
Conf.
Reasoning
01
GPT-6 Luna
Draw
1–1
31%
Kilmarnock’s home advantage is offset by their 2-6 record and 23 goals conceded, while St Johnstone have been steadier but inconsistent. Their recent 4-3 meeting and balanced season records suggest a competitive, moderate-scoring draw.
02
Claude Sonnet 5.5
ST Johnstone win
1–2
46%
Kilmarnock's poor defense (23 conceded, 6 losses) vs St Johnstone's better points tally and Fowler's scoring form favor a narrow away win.
03
Gemini 3.8 Flash
Draw
1–1
51%
Kilmarnock have struggled defensively with 23 conceded, but ST Johnstone have drawn three times and lack away dominance, pointing to a tightly contested split.
04
Grok 4.7
Draw
1–1
38%
Killie leaky (10-23) and Saints mixed (LDWDL); both fail to score often. Rugby Park edge offset by Killie form, so a tight 1-1 fits.
05
DeepSeek V4 Pro
ST Johnstone win
1–2
48%
Kilmarnock's poor form (6 losses, 23 conceded) and recent H2H loss at St Johnstone support an away edge; Fowler's 6 goals give the visitors a finishing threat.
06
Qwen 3.8 Max
ST Johnstone win
1–2
45%
Kilmarnock's dire defensive record (23 conceded in 10) and Fowler's 6 goals favour ST Johnstone; recent H2H was high-scoring, supporting both teams finding the net.
07
Meta Muse Spark 1.3
ST Johnstone win
1–2
48%
Kilmarnock leaking 26 goals in 11 with DLWLL form; St Johnstone steadier DWDLD with Fowler scoring six and recent 4-3 H2H edge.
08
Kimi K3
ST Johnstone win
1–2
48%
Kilmarnock leak goals (23 conceded, 6 losses) while St Johnstone are steadier with Fowler scoring; H2H is mixed but Saints' recent 4-3 win and better form give them a narrow edge.
09
GLM 5.3
Draw
1–1
45%
Both sides struggling: Kilmarnock 2W 6L at Rugby Park, St Johnstone inconsistent. Fowler's goals balance Kilmarnock's home edge; tight, low-scoring draw fits.
10
MiMo V2.6 Pro
ST Johnstone win
1–2
42%
Kilmarnock's 2W 6L with 23 conceded is poor despite Rugby Park; ST Johnstone's Fowler has 6 goals and won 4-3 in August. Tight, but away edge holds.
— Scoreline frequency

How often each scoreline showed up.

6 of 10 models settled on 1–2. That convergence is a strong scoreline signal—many fixtures fan out wider across the panel.

  • 1–2
    6 models
  • 1–1
    4 models

Bookmakers vs the AI panel

Bet365 · 2.30 / 3.60 / 2.88
Kilmarnock Market 41% · AI 0%
Draw Market 26% · AI 36%
ST Johnstone Market 33% · AI 64%

Grey: bookmaker prices as probabilities, margin removed. Lime: share of the 11 AI models picking each result.

Team news

Predicted lineups: Kilmarnock vs ST Johnstone

Each side's last starting XI, with players ruled out of this match marked. The confirmed lineups replace this about an hour before kickoff.

Kilmarnock

5-3-2 · XI v Dundee, 28 Oct
N. McCann
9 J. Hugill
9 Hugill
10 T. John-Jules
10 John-Jules
11 G. Kiltie
11 Kiltie
36 A. Tshibola
36 Tshibola
18 T. Lowery
18 Lowery
21 M. Schjønning-Larsen
21 Schjønning-Larsen
6 R. Deas
6 Deas
4 C. McCarthy
4 McCarthy
14 G. Stanger
14 Stanger
2 J. Brandon
2 Brandon
58 N. Mantl
58 Mantl

ST Johnstone

4-2-3-1 · XI v Motherwell, 28 Oct
S. Valakari
9 J. Fowler
9 Fowler
7 T. Steven
7 Steven
10 J. Gullan
10 Gullan
99 R. Paton
99 Paton
42 R. McAlear
42 McAlear
8 J. Holt
8 Holt
Left
2 E. Alıç
2 Alıç
3 C. Diabate
3 Diabate
19 D. Finlayson
19 Finlayson
26 M. Todd
26 Todd
1 T. Steward
1 Steward

1 of this XI is ruled out of this match or no longer at the club.

Season data

Premiership numbers for both sides, when they score and the players who carry them.

Kilmarnock

4-2-3-1
W-D-L
2-2-7
Goals
11-26
Clean sheets
2
Failed to score
4
Best win run
1
Penalties
1/1
When they score
15'30'45'60'75'90'
When they concede
15'30'45'60'75'90'

ST Johnstone

4-2-3-1
W-D-L
3-4-4
Goals
13-17
Clean sheets
1
Failed to score
3
Best win run
1
Penalties
2/3
When they score
15'30'45'60'75'90'
When they concede
15'30'45'60'75'90'

Key players · Kilmarnock

  • G. Kiltie 3 G · 0 A · 11 apps
  • J. Brandon 0 G · 2 A · 11 apps

Key players · ST Johnstone

  • J. Fowler 6 G · 1 A · 11 apps

Top scorers · Premiership

  1. 1 C. Durán Celtic 7
  2. 2 B. Nygren Celtic 6
  3. 3 J. Fowler ST Johnstone 6
  4. 4 R. Naderi Rangers 5
  5. 5 Cláudio Braga Heart Of Midlothian 5
Venue The BBSP Stadium Rugby Park, Kilmarnock
New at Kilmarnock Michael-John Kamson-Kamara (Heart Of Midlothian), N. Mantl (Arouca), C. McCarthy (Hull City)
New at ST Johnstone J. Campbell (Hibernian), J. Cotterill (Swansea), E. Alić (Zeljeznicar Sarajevo)
— Aggregated insights

What’s moving the panel.

01
Consensus favors ST Johnstone

60% of models lean away — the clearest cluster on this fixture before kickoff.

02
Low confidence

Mean 44% across the panel with real dispersion — compare unanimous calls vs split tickets in the model table.

03
xG tilt 1.00 vs 1.60

Derived from predicted scorelines (model means), not live match data — useful for pace vs vote-share sanity checks.

04
Match context

Expected-goals tilt and home-field rhythm (see xG on this page) usually explain whether the game stays open or compresses late.

Ask the Council about this match

Pro

10 AI models vote yes or no with this match's last-5 form, head-to-head, live status and the model picks above attached — not from memory. Then keep asking the same council follow-ups.

Match stats forecast

Corners, cards and shots from each side's last 10 matches at this venue, blended with the league average. Pure statistics, not an AI vote.

No AI
Metric Kilmarnock ST Johnstone Expected total Lean
Corners 5.0 4.6 9.6 Under 9.5 51% Ask AI
Yellow cards 1.8 1.6 3.4 Under 3.5 55% Ask AI
Shots 14.0 11.0 24.9 Over 24.5 52% Ask AI
Shots on target 5.0 3.1 8.1 Under 8.5 57% Ask AI

Sample: 10 matches per side. Over the last 90 days the corners lean hit 55% of 249 graded matches, cards 58% of 250. Probabilities are Poisson estimates for information only.

— Match context

Form, history, team news.

Kilmarnock
#12 · 8 PTS · GD -15
Last 5
L L W L D
6 GF · 12 GA
Recent fixtures
  • Dundee 3-1 L
  • Falkirk 3-0 L
  • Motherwell 3-2 W
  • Rangers 3-1 L
  • Heart Of Midlothian 1-1 D
Team news

No major injury updates in the current API snapshot.

ST Johnstone
#8 · 13 PTS · GD -4
Last 5
D L D W D
5 GF · 8 GA
Recent fixtures
  • Motherwell 2-2 D
  • Rangers 4-0 L
  • Dundee Utd 1-1 D
  • Aberdeen 0-1 W
  • Falkirk 1-1 D
Team news

No major injury updates in the current API snapshot.

— Head to head

Last five meetings.

KIL 2 · D 0 · STJ 3

STJ VS KIL
4-3
HOME WIN
Aug 2, 2026
STJ VS KIL
0-2
AWAY WIN
May 3, 2025
KIL VS STJ
3-1
HOME WIN
Feb 15, 2025
STJ VS KIL
1-0
HOME WIN
Nov 23, 2024
KIL VS STJ
0-3
AWAY WIN
Aug 11, 2024

Confidence trend

Cumulative average confidence in table order.

First model Last model

Betting tips (AI-signal view)

Educational only — not financial advice. We summarize how the AI picks cluster so you can cross-check with your own staking plan.

  • Lean with the plurality: when 0% of models side with Kilmarnock, treat that as the default script unless late team news breaks the assumptions.
  • Watch the draw lane at 40% — tight Premiership games often compress toward stalemates when both midfields win the second-ball.
  • If you chase “best bets today” narratives, require alignment between the headline pick and the score-frequency table; conflicting signals usually mean thinner edge.

Odds & analysis (implied probabilities)

Implied fair percentages from the model vote share (normalized to 100%) approximate how a balanced market might price the 1X2 if it mirrored this panel — useful for odds analysis homework even though we do not quote sportsbook ticks here.

Kilmarnock
~0%
implied lean
Draw
~40%
implied lean
ST Johnstone
~60%
implied lean

Over / under prediction (totals)

Model-derived xG sums to 2.60 goals in expectation. A notional totals line near 2.9 is consistent with that pace (rounded for readability). If your sportsbook posts a similar number, compare juice and live team news before deciding either side of the total.

Handicap prediction (spread-style read)

When Kilmarnock is priced as the stronger side in the model vote, a −1 handicap narrative only clears if the most common scorelines include multi-goal wins. Cross-check the score-frequency list: if tight one-goal wins dominate, Asian handicaps near pick’em or −0.5 / −0.75 splits often fit the story better than a full −1.5 sell.

BTTS prediction (both teams to score)

With combined offensive weight near 2.60 xG, a heuristic “both teams score” prior lands around 55% yes before defensive adjustments. If several top models forecast clean-sheet pathways, downgrade BTTS enthusiasm even when the raw xG sum looks juicy.

Best bet framing (consensus-led)

Our headline best bet label follows the consensus recommendation: ST Johnstone win. Pair that with the confidence band (Low) — high dispersion across models usually argues for smaller stake or pass, even when the headline pick looks tempting for a today prediction card on social.

Match overview

Looking for a today prediction on Kilmarnock vs ST Johnstone in Premiership? TuringStats aggregates multiple AI scorelines into one readable page so you can see who the models favor, the mean predicted score shown in the hero (1 - 2; the frequency chart below lists the most common exact scorelines), and implied splits before kickoff.

This prediction hub is written for readers comparing betting tips-style language with transparent model votes — not a single black-box call. The headline read is ST Johnstone win, with vote shares roughly 0% / 40% / 60% home, draw, and away (rounded).

If you are asking who will win Kilmarnock vs ST Johnstone, start with the consensus strip and model table, then cross-check form and injuries in Match context further down — that order keeps the strongest signals first.

Explore more

Keep browsing today prediction coverage and league hubs.

Related matches

— Journal

Articles linked to these clubs or AI forecasting.

Ask multiple AIs about this match.

10 models vote yes or no with this match's last-5 form, head-to-head, live status and our model picks attached — not from memory. Then ask follow-ups to the same council.