LOR 1-1 REN · 46% LIV 2-1 MAN · 56% WER 2-1 HAM · 53% ACM 2-1 FRO · 54% FCN 1-2 FCC · 53% OSA 1-0 MAL · 52% AND 2-0 OHL · 52% SAR 1-2 LIL · 54% LOM 1-1 STA · 45% ATL 2-0 REM · 57% ROS 2-0 GIM · 61% ATA 1-2 INT · 56% MAR 2-0 LEM · 63% GET 0-1 ATL · 59% LOR 1-1 REN · 46% LIV 2-1 MAN · 56% WER 2-1 HAM · 53% ACM 2-1 FRO · 54% FCN 1-2 FCC · 53% OSA 1-0 MAL · 52% AND 2-0 OHL · 52% SAR 1-2 LIL · 54% LOM 1-1 STA · 45% ATL 2-0 REM · 57% ROS 2-0 GIM · 61% ATA 1-2 INT · 56% MAR 2-0 LEM · 63% GET 0-1 ATL · 59%
Sports · Kalshi · Closes Jan 1, 2027

Who will win Heisman Trophy?

Heisman Trophy Winner

10 AI models
25% yes

0 lean yes · 10 lean no

Kalshi when AIs voted
17% yes

Now 5%

What each AI says

GPT-6.1 Sol

30% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a serious contender, but his No. 2 position in the latest Athletic poll leaves him behind Jeremiah Smith with other candidates still in contention. His elite QBR and 29-to-2 touchdown-to-interception ratio support a substantial chance, though Miami’s head-to-head loss to CJ Carr hurts his case; a dominant finish or a stumble by Smith could put him on top.

Claude Opus 5.5

17% yes

Probably not — Mensah sits No. 2 in The Athletic's poll behind Jeremiah Smith, and the head-to-head loss to CJ Carr hurt his case. His efficiency is elite (29 TD, 2 INT, top QBR), and voters usually favor QBs, so he is a genuine contender but not the favorite with a few weeks left. A big finish, an ACC title run, or a stumble by Smith could flip the race in his favor.

Gemini 4 Argon

32% yes

Probably not — while Darian Mensah ranks #2 in recent Heisman polls and leads the nation in QBR with 29 touchdowns to just 2 interceptions, he currently trails frontrunner Jeremiah Smith and his campaign was hurt by a head-to-head loss against CJ Carr. However, because the Heisman historically favors elite quarterbacks over wide receivers, a dominant finish to the regular season coupled with a conference championship performance could easily vault him past Smith to win the trophy.

Grok 4.7

22% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a legitimate contender (No. 2 in The Athletic’s post-Week 11 poll, elite QBR and efficiency) but trails Jeremiah Smith and was dinged by Miami’s head-to-head loss. A late surge or Smith stumble could still flip the race before voting.

DeepSeek V4 Pro

22% yes

Likely no — Mensah is a strong contender but currently trails Jeremiah Smith in the latest Heisman poll, and Miami’s head-to-head loss to CJ Carr has damaged his candidacy. His efficiency numbers are elite, but Heisman voters often favor a signature win or late-season surge, which he hasn’t yet secured. The main risk to this view is if Smith falters and Mensah closes with dominant performances in Miami’s remaining games.

Tencent Hy4

28% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a serious contender with elite efficiency and a recent No. 2 Heisman poll position, but he trails Jeremiah Smith and has head-to-head narrative damage from Miami’s loss to CJ Carr. With several weeks of games, conference championships, and voter momentum still to play out, a late surge or dominant finishing schedule could prove this wrong.

Meta Muse Spark 1.3

28% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a top contender at No.2 behind Jeremiah Smith with elite efficiency (1st in QBR, 29 TDs to 2 INTs). But he trails Smith and was damaged by the head-to-head loss to CJ Carr, leaving him needing help. A late surge or rival slip could still prove me wrong.

NVIDIA Nemotron 3 Ultra

30% yes

Likely no — Mensah is a top contender with elite efficiency stats and a No. 2 Heisman poll ranking, but he trails Jeremiah Smith and was damaged by Miami's head-to-head loss to CJ Carr, which historically hurts voter perception. The race remains fluid with several games and conference championships left, and a single standout performance by a rival could shift momentum decisively.

GLM 5.3

22% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a genuine contender (No. 2 in The Athletic's poll, top QBR, 29 TDs to 2 INTs), but he trails Jeremiah Smith and took a candidacy hit from Miami's head-to-head loss to CJ Carr. Remaining games and championship weekend could still shift the race in his favor, which is the main risk to a No call.

MiMo V2.6 Pro

22% yes

Probably not — Mensah is a legitimate contender but currently sits No. 2 behind Jeremiah Smith in The Athletic's latest Heisman poll, and a head-to-head loss to CJ Carr has hurt his case. His efficiency numbers (top QBR, 29:2 TD:INT) are strong, but he needs Smith to falter down the stretch and likely needs a conference title game appearance to overtake him. What could prove me wrong: if Miami wins out impressively and Smith's production dips, Mensah's efficiency profile could flip enough voters to win.

News the AIs read (Nov 18)
- As of 2026-11-18, Darian Mensah is a real Heisman contender, but the race is still unresolved and no current fact confirms he will win. - On 2026-11-17, The Athletic listed Mensah as No. 2 in its latest Heisman poll after Week 11, behind Jeremiah Smith. - Mensah’s recent form on 2026-11-17 was 30-for-41 passing for 382 yards and 1 touchdown vs. Duke. - His 2026 season line is roughly 3,076 passing yards, 29 passing TDs, and 2 interceptions, with ESPN listing him first nationally in QBR and several outlets noting his strong efficiency. - A 2026-11-10 Miami Herald piece said Mensah was hurt by Miami’s head-to-head loss to CJ Carr, which damaged his candidacy. - No injury or suspension for Mensah was confirmed in the gathered sources. - The Heisman winner will be publicly known when the award is decided, so the outcome date is not a game date; it is still pending in late 2026.
Resolution rules
If Darian Mensah wins the College Football Heisman Trophy in the 2026-2027 college football season, then the market resolves to Yes. Kalshi is not affiliated, associated, authorized, endorsed by, or in any way officially connected with the NCAA. All trademarks, logos, and brand names are the property of their respective owners.

Market prices: Kalshi. TuringStats is not affiliated with Kalshi.

More sports questions